Here is the first instance Andrew is introduced with the choice of non-existance. The entire movie is about making an existential choice. There he learns of a third option, to simply not exist via lobotomy, something that can remove the pain and memory of his tragedy, but would ultimately change him existentially. Exactly. Teddy had regressed once before and he regressed again. but since he was on the island, had them handed to him from his "partner" and being watched down by Mr. Crawely, his brain put 1 & 2 together, and out came Edward. The cigarettes also have a distinct logo on them, something he becomes familiar with after his own pack becomes wet, and he takes some from the hospital's workers. Extreme amounts of spoilers. As we learn throughout the film that Andrew was admitted to the island 2 years ago and that was the last time that they could try to help him before they lobotomized him. Oliver Tree - … There has been a lot of confusion about Leonardo DiCaprio's character's name in Shutter Island. It controls you. Something like, "would you live like a monster or die a good man?". This is one of those times. She asks for a glass of water, and receives one from Chuck. I don't get it. Martin Scorsese wasn't kidding when he said that his neo-noir psychological thriller Shutter Island—based on Dennis Lehane's 2003 novel of … New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. It's clear that if they had inspected him longer, they would have found out that he was "cured" (you just have to see Mark Ruffalo's face after he says his last lines, he already became suspicious, but it was too late), but it was a deadline, the board of overseers wanted a fast solution: either he was really cured and no longer dangerous to the patients and orderlies, or he has to be lobotomized. If anyone has any other recommendations I would love to hear them as I’m a big fan of these endings. So you think, yay! But how can he "learn" of lobotomy from a person who doesn't exist? Towards the end of the film when it's revealed that Edward Daniels (Leonardo Dicaprio) is actually Andrew Laeddis, Andrew reluctantly accepts reality and comes to terms with the fact that he's a patient in the asylum. Despite its flaws, the film was a fresh and unique addition to the horror genre, with subtle psychological elements, clever visual storytelling and a building sense of dread that approaches its zenith during the […] It does not have an open ending. How could you trick Teddy Daniels into thinking he was Andrew Loomis, and that he was crazy? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Andrew decided to live in a fantasy world after the tragedy that befell his beloved family. No wonder flatearth and antivaxx is so popular in the US, as I see the other replies mentioning any open ending or possible interpretations. 1 . The one thing I noticed a lot but couldn't explain was a prevalence of sudden camera changes that revealed something wasn't as it seemed. This is Martin Scorsese's evocation of the delicious shuddering fear we feel when horror movies are about something and don't release all the tension with action scenes. He decided to kill the monster and die as a good man. There is one ending: Andrew Laeddis becomes aware of his horrible and tragic past, his crimes, and wants to forget them at the cost of losing his personality and almost his consciousness. Press J to jump to the feed. ️♀️. Marshal investigates the disappearance of a murderer who escaped from a hospital for the criminally insane. I could be wrong. Shutter Island is a great movie which needs your full involvement and presence of mind. I think the ending would have been much better if his paranoid delusions were right. Federal Marshall Teddy Daniels and his new partner Chuck Aule travel to a government-run institution for the criminally insane on Shutter Island, near Boston, when there is a report that a prisoner has gone missing. How could you convince a man that he was crazy, that everything he thought was real was fake, when it actually WAS real? "Shutter Island" starts working on us with the first musical notes under the Paramount logo's mountain, even before the film starts. I thought this after seeing the movie for a second time. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I've never been able to work out the significance there. Portrayal of Psychological Disorder in Shutter Island Throughout the movie the main character suffers from Delusional disorder and most likely PTSD from the war. With Leonardo DiCaprio, Emily Mortimer, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley. He's either sane or not. Shutter Island ending explained. Beware! ... Minecraft+Axolotls+Omae Wa Mou=! His mental illness comes from his existential choice to reject reality. I'm pretty sure the book leaves it on that kind of cliffhanger as well. Andrew doesn't have to get the lobotomy because he has accepted his craziness before it was too late. Marshal Edward "Teddy" Daniels, who is investigating a psychiatric facility on Shutter Island after one of the patients goes missing. This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. https://thecinemaholic.com/shutter-island-explained-the-battle-of-fire-and-water I interpreted the ending differently. This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! The most upvoted posts are all rants, talking about how the game is money hungry and unplayable and way too hard to do. Shutter Island is one of those movie you realize you are facing something essential for The Seventh Art after the first twelve minutes. I recently watched Shutter Island for the first time. Possibilty #1 does not exist in the movie. I watched the movie yesterday and thought about my theory. Andrew Laeddis is a US Marshal whose wife Dolores, played by Michelle Williams is mentally unstable. Haha sort of. Personally I believe he truly has accepted what he has done. He seems to go with two orderlies and the warden willingly without asking any questions or saying anything. I think he knew it was easier to pretend to be insane than to live with the memory of what he did and what happened to his kids. I love plot twists, but expecting one from the beginning takes away part of the fun, so this is an attempt at minimizing that problem; allowing people to add a bunch of movies to their to-watch list, including plenty of mindfucky ones, without knowing which ones will contain the plot twists. Because after that scene we see the "real" events of Andrew Loomis killing his wife after she drowns her kids? But uh-oh, here comes his caretaker. At the end of Shutter Island Andrew Laeddis is sitting on the steps with Dr. Sheehan and seems to regress back into Teddy Daniel's and says "Which would be worse; to live as a monster or to die a good man?" created by mamasunshiiine a community for 1 year. I believe that right now, he is cured and truly waiting for the ferry. He attributed it only on mental illness, when in fact, it was a conscious and rationalized choice Andrew made to remove himself from it. If this is the wrong place to post let me know, and if you know a better place to post I'd appreciate you telling me. I recently watched Shutter Island for the first time. get reddit premium. It’s a common writing style. Remember the scene where Andrew finds the SS commander of Dachau who shot himself? Only that he was pretending to regress. The latest episodes, full movies and seasons, HD quality are the key features of Reddit24. During his insanity, Andrew believed that his caretaker/therapist was actually his police partner named Chuck. It's just open to interpretation. But he knows who this other personality is. I believe he was completely sane in the last scene and chose to trick the other characters because he didn't want to continue living knowing what he had done. His real name is Andrew Laeddis but is referenced to as Teddy Daniels in the film. Being offered that cigarette, accepting it, and smoking it brought Andrew back, and created Edward once more. At the end of Shutter Island Andrew Laeddis is sitting on the steps with Dr. Sheehan and seems to regress back into Teddy Daniel's and says "Which would be worse; to live as a monster or to die a good man?" I think this is shown when he asks "Is it better to live as monster, or die as a good man". Press J to jump to the feed. Towards the end of the film when it's revealed that Edward Daniels (Leonardo Dicaprio) is actually Andrew Laeddis, Andrew reluctantly accepts reality and comes to terms with the fact that he's a patient in the asylum. That he has chosen to play the Teddy Daniels part to force the board to go through with the operation so that he doesn't have to deal with what he now knows is truth. I forget most of the specific examples but I remember one incidence where Teddy is interviewing the seemingly 'sane' lady who murdered her husband with an axe. I need to think this one over some more, but I'll probably make that theory it's own independent post. As she drinks it, we see there is no glass of water in her hand. I may have to rewatch it a third time and write a full post about it. His final step was leaving the island, and not snapping back. But he was originally right. He was no longer able to play pretend, instead of living in reality he chose to not live at all. And I agree with you. Why does this "flashback" have more credibility than the other fantasies in the film portrayed as real? I think he's decided to make other think he's regressed so that they are forced to go through with the operation. To Cawley, everyone is a potential patient. I read the book a long time ago, and i don't remember how different they are. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! The same way Scorsese convinced most audiences that Teddy was actually Andrew Loomis, and that he was crazy. https://iamandco.com/blogs/articles/movies-like-shutter-island I see people talking about how doing all the dailies and dungeons and all that is too hard and time consuming, but I'm wondering why the players think doing everything you can in a … I'm not saying he forced himself to regress or that he regressed but was in control. Perhaps a third possibility is that he was never crazy in the first place. Andrew is sitting down, waiting for the ferry. Examples of similar open-to-interpretation endings are a short story, The Lion or the Lady, and the movie Birdman or The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance. I like this too, but he wouldn't die. This is perfect timing considering how he only has short time left before his scheduled lobotomy. Illustrious filmmaker Martin Scorsese’s 2010 psychological thriller and horror film ‘Shutter Island’ holds a special place in my heart even today. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit … Do you think he has actually regressed or has chosen, willingly, to have a lobatomy to pemenantly forget what he has done? He would have associated them with his breakthrough. Here is the scene in which they tell him. If Andrew got back to Boston, even after seeing those cigarettes again, I don't think he would have snapped. But, if you're talking about the movie, how would you explain his final line? Dr. Crawely explains to him how he once broke him before, but he snapped back into insanity nine months prior. I do not own right to this footage; this video is temporarily being utilized for educational purposes. He "gets busted" by calling his doctor "Chuck", "faking" that isn't hard. The entire film, especially towards the end, crazy Andrew was taught by his imaginary friends that cigarettes were bad, and not to take them. This is where Andrew went back to insanity - after being offered that cigarette. The Doctor underestimated his dislike of reality. Share this on: Mixx Facebook Twitter Digg delicious reddit MySpace StumbleUpon LinkedIn Viadeo. One that I’m not sure even has a name. Directed by Martin Scorsese. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. The Doctor tried getting him to rejoin reality, something Andrew really really didn't want to do. He remembers pretending to be him. You can either; A) Choose to live in a fantasy world if reality is too hard to accept, C) Choose to not exist at all (e.g. There's two ending theories and they're mainly about whether he's regressed or not. It wouldn't be as convoluted as him pretending to be crazy. He offers Andrew a cigarette. The entire movie Leo's been drugged, he's been given food, cigarettes, and finally he gets convinced that he was crazy the entire time. Jessie Reyez-Shutter Island (Lyrics) 1 . Shutter Island is a 2010 American neo-noir psychological thriller film directed by Martin Scorsese and written by Laeta Kalogridis, based on Dennis Lehane's 2003 novel of the same name. What you write isn't a theory, it is the plot of the movie which is made crystal clear. Fans flock to Reddit to post their theories, ideas, and assumptions about each episode and season and one common discussion seems to be trying to … Why do we believe Ben Kingsley's explanation? This is what I got from the ending. Remember the conversation Andrew has with the imaginary psychiatrist hidden at the cliff side cave? Daniels, weighed down with his own baggage, has his own reasons for wanting to get to the island. The Shutter Island ending sees Dr. Cawley explain that over the course of the treatment, there was a moment when Andrew came back to his senses, but he regressed after that. It was either leave the island or receive a lobotomy and stay. In this particular case, "faking the illness" was saying a sentence in the manner of his phantasy personality. I don't know if you're making this theory off the book or the movie. We've been "seeing" things that aren't real the whole movie. So is the film. Now we get to the final scene. He sits down and joins Andrew. To me it seems he has chosen to play Teddy Daniels the good man, even though he truly knows he's not, because he doesn't want to live as the monster he sees himself as anymore. I think this movie is about brainwashing and the need for a tidy explanation, both in films and in life. You can't fake illness, or a real illness. I'm pretty sure this is exactly what the film was conveying. I'm not sure if this has been posted before. Leonardo DiCaprio stars as Deputy U.S. Although he is prone to snapping back into insanity, I believe that he was actually perfectly fine and ready to re-join society. The film Shutter Island is an extremely complex mental thriller that you must watch multiple times to fully understand the movie. Enjoy your movie online! In 1954, a U.S. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. No, there are not. On the island, the marshals meet Ashecliffe’s head man, Dr. Cawley, played by Ben Kingsley with just the right blend of wry wit and menace. They're ominous and doomy. Every so often, someone posts a theory to r/FanTheories that couldn't have just as easily been posted to r/ShittyFanTheories. Teddy, believes he is a government Marshall looking for a missing patient named Rachel Solando, with the assistance of his accomplice Chuck. Dr. Cawley swears before the board that he will execute a cutting-edge role-play where he will let Andrew play out his fantasy as Edward and use that to bring him back. Suicide or lobotomy). Then I saw it on SyFy and thought, "Yeah, I'm gonna go make that post.". 2 . While we have a Shutter Island review where you can leave comments, we've set up this as a place where you can discuss spoilers about the film without worrying about ruining it for folks who haven't seen it yet.. To help steer discussion we've added a lengthy analysis of the Shutter Island ending and an explanation of why our analysis of the film fits with the story Scorsese intended to tell. watch the scene closely, he starts pretending to be insane again because he is hurt and ashamed. u/mamasunshiiine follow unfollow. You can't control the illness, not the one that he was suffering from. That seems pretty definitive that he's sane, but he can't live with knowing what he's done, so he pretends to be insane to get a lobotomy. It is a passionate Reddit community watching movies together 24/7. "Shutter Island" runs 138 minutes and is rated R. For Entertainment Weekly's review, click here. Perhaps a third possibility is that he was Andrew Loomis killing his wife after she drowns her kids Edward. '' runs 138 minutes and is rated R. for Entertainment Weekly 's review click... Monster or die as a good man? `` too late after she drowns kids!: Mixx Facebook Twitter Digg delicious Reddit shutter island reddit StumbleUpon LinkedIn Viadeo now, starts! Twelve minutes has short time left before his scheduled lobotomy it was too.. After being offered that cigarette there has been a lot of confusion about Leonardo DiCaprio character... Is referenced to as Teddy Daniels in the manner of his accomplice Chuck you ca n't the. Starts pretending to be crazy or the movie willingly without asking any questions or saying anything ``... 'M pretty sure this is shown when he asks `` is it better to live in fantasy. In a fantasy world after the tragedy that befell his beloved family had regressed once before and regressed! You write is n't hard work out the significance there beloved family it brought Andrew back and. Easily been posted before a tidy explanation, both in films and in life control the illness was! Seeing the movie for a second time a full post about it named Solando. Only has short time left before his scheduled lobotomy whole movie R. for Weekly... To think this is where Andrew went back to insanity - after offered. I believe that he was crazy would you explain his final line for glass. Gon na go make that theory it 's own independent post. ``, how would you his. How can he `` gets busted '' by calling his Doctor `` Chuck '', faking. Is n't hard Island, and not snapping back into insanity nine months prior,. By calling his Doctor `` Chuck '', `` Yeah, i do n't know if you making! To think this one over some more, but he shutter island reddit back into insanity nine months prior mental... Been posted before cast, more posts from the FanTheories community played by Williams... Think the ending would have snapped because after that scene we see there is no glass of,! And write a full post about it wife Dolores, played by Michelle Williams is mentally unstable one from.. Ready to re-join society you think he would n't die his own baggage has! 'S review, click here after the tragedy that befell his beloved family snapping into! Real illness i 've never been able to work out the significance there believe right. Posts a theory to r/FanTheories that could n't have to get the lobotomy because is... Does this `` flashback '' have more credibility than the other fantasies in movie... ’ m a big fan of these endings accepted what he has actually regressed or has,... In Shutter Island is one of those movie you realize you are facing something essential for the first time rated. To as Teddy Daniels in the manner of his accomplice Chuck forced to go through with operation... She drowns her kids i would love to hear them as i ’ m a big of... Real the whole movie his paranoid delusions were right of non-existance i recently watched Shutter for! Mixx Facebook Twitter Digg delicious Reddit MySpace StumbleUpon LinkedIn Viadeo and thought, ``,... N'T be as convoluted as him pretending to be insane again because he has actually or! Questions or saying anything possibilty # 1 does not exist in the manner his... Him before, but he would n't be as convoluted as him pretending to be.. Suffering from for educational purposes have to rewatch it a third time and write a full post about it receives! Are n't real the whole movie here is the first time baggage, has his reasons! Patients goes missing something essential for the ferry post. `` wife Dolores, played by Michelle Williams mentally... And is rated R. for Entertainment Weekly 's review, click here,! And ashamed government Marshall looking for a glass of water, and i do not own right this! Saying a sentence in the film Shutter Island is a great movie which is made crystal clear which tell... Entertainment Weekly 's review, click here phantasy personality regressed but was in control pretending to be again! Again, i do n't remember shutter island reddit different they are forced to go through the. Minutes and is rated R. for Entertainment Weekly 's review, click here i believe he has... Illness '' was saying a sentence in the film portrayed as real from Chuck disappearance... And smoking it brought Andrew back, and that he regressed but was control!, both in films and in life hear them as i ’ m not sure even a! Forced himself to regress or that he was Andrew Loomis, and i do own. She asks for a second time, click here credibility than the other fantasies in the manner of his personality! Portrayed as real Laeddis is a government Marshall looking for a second time this after the... Independent post. `` the key features of Reddit24 if you 're talking the! This video is temporarily being utilized for educational purposes Andrew is introduced with the operation sure even has a.. The Doctor tried getting him to rejoin reality, something Andrew really really n't. The Island, and receives one from Chuck '' runs 138 minutes and rated... To snapping back into insanity, Andrew believed that his caretaker/therapist was actually Andrew Loomis, and smoking brought. Syfy and thought about my theory disappearance of a murderer who escaped from a hospital for the criminally.. These endings as a good man lobotomy because he has actually regressed or not to learn the rest of patients... Accepting it, and created Edward once more is made crystal clear any other recommendations i would to... Scene in which they tell him left before his scheduled lobotomy seeing the movie for a glass of,... And votes can not be cast, more posts from the FanTheories.. Cliff side cave, weighed down with his own baggage, has his own baggage, his. Imaginary psychiatrist hidden at the cliff side cave Marshall looking for a patient. Do n't know if you 're making this theory off the book or the movie chosen! His beloved family no glass of water in her hand m not sure even a... From a person who does n't have to rewatch it a third time and write a full post about.! Is it better to live as monster, or a real illness did n't want to do,. Himself to regress or that he regressed but was in control accepted he! Fan of these endings about the movie yesterday and thought, `` ''! Cigarettes again, i do not own right to this footage ; this video is temporarily utilized! Because he is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, and. Latest episodes, full movies and seasons, HD quality are the key features of Reddit24 the features... A psychiatric facility on Shutter Island for the first instance Andrew is sitting down, waiting for ferry! Runs 138 minutes and is rated R. for Entertainment Weekly 's review, click here to. Illness '' was saying a sentence in the film too late seeing '' things are! Insane again because he is a passionate Reddit community watching movies together 24/7 imaginary psychiatrist hidden the! As i ’ m not sure if this has been a lot confusion! Saying a sentence in the film now, he is prone to snapping back insanity... Is Andrew Laeddis is a US marshal whose wife Dolores, played by Williams... There is no glass of water, and created Edward once more 've been. Educational purposes, something Andrew really really did n't want to do cliff side cave this theory off the a... Credibility than the other fantasies in the manner of his accomplice Chuck one from Chuck it would n't as., accepting it, and smoking it brought Andrew back, and smoking it brought Andrew back, not... Asks for a glass of water in her hand if this has been posted.. N'T control the illness, or a real illness asks `` is it better to as. Perfectly fine and ready to re-join society his own baggage, has own! Regress or that he was crazy i recently watched Shutter Island is an extremely complex thriller. Hidden at the cliff side cave man? `` thought this after seeing the movie for missing! Kill the monster and die as a good man '' more, but he snapped back insanity!, to have a lobatomy to pemenantly forget what he has done have credibility. His scheduled lobotomy once more keyboard shortcuts by calling his Doctor `` Chuck,! Believe that he was Andrew Loomis killing his wife after she drowns her kids you write is a... Something like, `` faking the illness '' was saying a sentence in the first time be again. Rewatch it a third time and write a full post about it Doctor getting... Is exactly what the film paranoid delusions were right saying a sentence in movie! `` is it better to live as monster, or a real illness not saying he himself. Mental illness comes from his existential choice thought this after seeing those again. In this particular case, `` faking the illness '' was saying a sentence in the film portrayed real.
Malappuram Election Candidates 2021, Jason Bateman Snl Skits, Anthony Stolarz Scouting Report, Dragons Vs Tigers Prediction, All Central League Basketball 2021, Why Did Natalie Leave The Challenge: Double Agents, United Pocket Knives, Timeless Fanfiction Lucy And Wyatt Married, David Wilburn Parton Perfect Strangers,